Probabilistic seismic vulnerability assessment of reinforced concrete moment frames exposed to corrosion

Document Type : Research Article


department of civil Engineering, Islamic Azad University, Science and research branch


Earthquakes and damages caused by corrosive environmental conditions are two important factors that threaten the desirable performance of structures in the coastal cities of the Persian Gulf in southern Iran. Taking into account both of these risks in the analysis and design of structures can reduce the loss of life and can lead to significant economic savings. In recent years, studies on the probabilistic seismic vulnerability assessment of structures have been developed. In this paper, a risk-based approach is used for seismic evaluation of reinforced concrete moment frames with medium ductility that are exposed to damage due to chloride-based corrosion of rebars in 4 important port cities of southern Iran (including Bushehr, Assaluyeh, Bandarabbas and Chabahar). A total of 18 reinforced concrete moment frames with different number of stories and in increments of 10 years after the initiation of corrosion, were subjected to incremental dynamic analysis (IDA). Then, using the risk integral, the annual probability of collapse for frames in the studied cities was obtained and evaluated. The results of this study show that over time after the initiation of corrosion, the probability of collapse of structures increases sharply, which indicates the high need for risk-based approach to evaluate and seismic design of structures that are exposed to damages due to aggressive environments.


Main Subjects

[1] A.T. Council, S.E.A.o. California, Tentative Provisions for the Development of Seismic Regulations for Buildings: A Cooperative Effort with the Design Professions, Building Code Interests, and the Research Community, Department of Commerce, National Bureau of Standards, 1978.
[2] N. Luco, B.R. Ellingwood, R.O. Hamburger, J.D. Hooper, J.K. Kimball, C.A. Kircher, Risk-targeted versus current seismic design maps for the conterminous United States, (2007).
[3] J. Douglas, T. Ulrich, C. Negulescu, Risk-targeted seismic design maps for mainland France, Natural Hazards, 65(3) (2013) 1999-2013.
[4] V. Silva, H. Crowley, P. Bazzurro, Exploring risk-targeted hazard maps for Europe, Earthquake Spectra, 32(2) (2016) 1165-1186.
[5] R. Vacareanu, F. Pavel, I. Craciun, V. Coliba, C. Arion, A. Aldea, C. Neagu, Risk-targeted maps for Romania, Journal of Seismology, 22(2) (2018) 407-417.
[6] A. Kharazian, S. Molina, J.J. Galiana-Merino, N. Agea-Medina, Risk-targeted hazard maps for Spain, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 19(13) (2021) 5369-5389.
[7] A.R. Taherian, A. Kalantari, Risk-targeted seismic design maps for Iran, Journal of Seismology, 23(6) (2019) 1299-1311.‏
[8] D.-E. Choe, P. Gardoni, D. Rosowsky, T. Haukaas, Seismic fragility estimates for reinforced concrete bridges subject to corrosion, Structural Safety, 31(4) (2009) 275-283.
[9] A. Alipour, B. Shafei, M. Shinozuka, Performance evaluation of deteriorating highway bridges located in high seismic areas, Journal of Bridge Engineering, 16(5) (2011) 597-611.
[10] J. Ghosh, J.E. Padgett, Aging considerations in the development of time-dependent seismic fragility curves, Journal of Structural Engineering, 136(12) (2010) 1497-1511.
[11] H. Yalcyn, M. Ergun, The prediction of corrosion rates of reinforcing steels in concrete, Cement and concrete research, 26(10) (1996) 1593-1599.
[12] T. Liu, R. Weyers, Modeling the dynamic corrosion process in chloride contaminated concrete structures, Cement and Concrete research, 28(3) (1998) 365-379.
[13] C. Li, H. Hao, H. Li, K. Bi, Seismic fragility analysis of reinforced concrete bridges with chloride induced corrosion subjected to spatially varying ground motions, International Journal of Structural Stability and Dynamics, 16(05) (2016) 1550010.
[14] M.M. Kashani, L.N. Lowes, A.J. Crewe, N.A. Alexander, Phenomenological hysteretic model for corroded reinforcing bars including inelastic buckling and low-cycle fatigue degradation, Computers & Structures, 156 (2015) 58-71.
[15] M.M. Kashani, L.N. Lowes, A.J. Crewe, N.A. Alexander, Computational modelling strategies for nonlinear response prediction of corroded circular RC bridge piers, Advances in Materials Science and Engineering, 2016 (2016).
[16] E. Afsar Dizaj, R. Madandoust, M.M. Kashani, Probabilistic seismic vulnerability analysis of corroded reinforced concrete frames including spatial variability of pitting corrosion, Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 114 (2018) 97-112.
[17] E. Afsar Dizaj, M.M. Kashani, Nonlinear structural performance and seismic fragility of corroded reinforced concrete structures: modelling guidelines, European Journal of Environmental and Civil Engineering, (2021) 1-30.‏
[18] E. Afsar Dizaj, M.R. Salami, M.M. Kashani, Seismic vulnerability assessment of ageing reinforced concrete structures under real mainshock-aftershock ground motions, Structure and Infrastructure Engineering, (2021) 1-17.
[19] J. Žižmond, M. Dolšek, Formulation of risk‐targeted seismic action for the force‐based seismic design of structures, Earthquake Engineering & Structural Dynamics, 48(12) (2019) 1406-1428.
[20] H.-H. Tsang, J.L. Wilson, E.F. Gad, Collapse probability of soft-storey building in Australia and implications for risk-based seismic design, Australian Journal of Structural Engineering, 21(4) (2020) 307-319.
[21] M. Khademi, M. Mansoori, M. Hosseini, Risk-targeted seismic design of reinforced concrete moment-resisting-frame buildings, Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers-Structures and Buildings, (2021) 1-14.
[22] Building and Housing Research Center (BHRC), Iranian code of practice for seismic resistant design of buildings (standard no. 2800 (IS 2800-05)), 4th edition Tehran, Iran: BHRC (2008). (In Persian)
[23] R.P. Kennedy, Performance-goal based (risk informed) approach for establishing the SSE site specific response spectrum for future nuclear power plants, Nuclear Engineering and Design, 241(3) (2011) 648-656.
[24] American Society of Civil Engineers, Reston, VA. Minimum Design Loads for Buildings and Other Structures (ASCE 7-10), ASCE (2010).
[25] C.A. Goulet, C.B. Haselton, J. Mitrani‐Reiser, J.L. Beck, G.G. Deierlein, K.A. Porter, J.P. Stewart, Evaluation of the seismic performance of a code‐conforming reinforced‐concrete frame building—from seismic hazard to collapse safety and economic losses, Earthquake Engineering & Structural Dynamics, 36(13) (2007) 1973-1997.
[26] W. Duckett, Risk analysis and the acceptable probability of failure, Structural Engineer, 83(15) (2005).
[27] P. Fajfar, M. Dolšek, A practice‐oriented estimation of the failure probability of building structures, Earthquake Engineering & Structural Dynamics, 41(3) (2012) 531-547.
[28] M. Erdik, K. Sesetyan, M. Demircioglu, C. Tuzun, D. Giardini, L. Gulen, S. Akkar, M. Zare, Assessment of seismic hazard in the Middle East and Caucasus: EMME (Earthquake Model of Middle East) project, in:  Proc. of 15th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, 2012.
[29] D. Giardini, L. Danciu, M. Erdik, K. Şeşetyan, M.B. Demircioğlu Tümsa, S. Akkar, L. Gülen, M. Zare, Seismic hazard map of the Middle East, Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 16(8) (2018) 3567-3570.
[30] P. Ghoddousi, E. Ganjian, T. Parhizkar, A. Ramezanianpour, Concrete technology in the environmental conditions of Persian Gulf, BHRC Publication, No. B, 283 (1998).
[31] M.G. Stewart, D.V. Rosowsky, Time-dependent reliability of deteriorating reinforced concrete bridge decks, Structural safety, 20(1) (1998) 91-109.
[32] R. McGee, Modelling of durability performance of Tasmanian bridges, ICASP8 applications of statistics and probability in civil engineering, 1 (1999) 297-306.
[33] A. A. Ramezanianpour, E. Jahangiri, F. Modi, B. Ahmadi, Evaluation and modification of the useful life estimation model provided by FIB for environmental conditions and materials of the Persian Gulf, Journal of Oceanography, 5 (17) (2014) 101-112. (In Persian)
[34] M. Ghanoonibagha, M.A. Shayanfar, S. Asgarani, M. Zabihi Samani, Service-life prediction of reinforced concrete structures in tidal zone, Journal Of Marine Engineering, 12(24) (2017) 13-22. (In Persian)
[35] J.S. Kong, A.N. Ababneh, D.M. Frangopol, Y. Xi, Reliability analysis of chloride penetration in saturated concrete, Probabilistic Engineering Mechanics, 17(3) (2002) 305-315.
[36] C. Fang, K. Lundgren, L. Chen, C. Zhu, Corrosion influence on bond in reinforced concrete, Cement and concrete research, 34(11) (2004) 2159-2167.
[37] K.A.T. Vu, M.G. Stewart, Structural reliability of concrete bridges including improved chloride-induced corrosion models, Structural safety, 22(4) (2000) 313-333.
[38] Y. Du, L. Clark, A. Chan, Residual capacity of corroded reinforcing bars, Magazine of Concrete Research, 57(3) (2005) 135-147.
[39] M. Saifullah, Effect of reinforced corrosion on bond strength in reinforced concrete, The University of Birmingham, 1994.
[40] B.D. Scott, R. Park, M.J. Priestley, Stress-strain behavior of concrete confined by overlapping hoops at low and high strain rates, in:  Journal Proceedings, 1982, pp. 13-27.
[41] J.S. Pugh, L.N. Lowes, D.E. Lehman, Nonlinear line-element modeling of flexural reinforced concrete walls, Engineering Structures, 104 (2015) 174-192.
[42] M.R. Salami, Seismic performance of buildings considering mainshock-aftershocks: improvement in record selection and advanced nonlinear beam-column model for RC framed structures, University of Bristol, 2017.
[43] National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), Guidelines for nonlinear structural analysis and design of buildings, part IIb reinforced concrete moment frames. Commerce Department, NIST grant contract report; 17-917-46v3 (2017).
[44] W.M. Ghannoum, J.P. Moehle, Dynamic collapse analysis of a concrete frame sustaining column axial failures, ACI Structural journal, 109(3) (2012) 403.
[45] K.J. Elwood, M.O. Eberhard, Effective stiffness of reinforced concrete columns, ACI Structural Journal, 106(4) (2009) 476.
[46] E. Spacone, F.C. Filippou, F.F. Taucer, Fibre beam–column model for non‐linear analysis of R/C frames: Part I. Formulation, Earthquake Engineering & Structural Dynamics, 25(7) (1996) 711-725.
[47] E. Afsar Dizaj, R. Madandoust, M.M. Kashani, Exploring the impact of chloride-induced corrosion on seismic damage limit states and residual capacity of reinforced concrete structures, Structure and Infrastructure Engineering, 14(6) (2018) 714-729.
[48] F. McKenna, OpenSees: a framework for earthquake engineering simulation, Computing in Science & Engineering, 13(4) (2011) 58-66.
[49] G. Stefanou, M. Fragiadakis, Nonlinear dynamic analysis of frames with stochastic non-Gaussian material properties, Engineering structures, 31(8) (2009) 1841-1850.
[50] M.P. Berry, M.O. Eberhard, Performance modeling strategies for modern reinforced concrete bridge columns, 2006.
[51] F.J. Vecchio, M.B. Emara, Shear deformations in reinforced concrete frames, ACI Structural journal, 89(1) (1992) 46-56.
[52] A.T. Council, Quantification of building seismic performance factors, US Department of Homeland Security, FEMA, 2009.‏
[53] H.-M. MR, Earthquake loss estimation methodology, Technical and user’s manual. Department of Homeland Security, Federal Emergency Management Agency, Mitigation Division. Washington, DC, (2010).