Evaluation of Grout Curtain Performance in Seepage Control from Rock Formations by 3D Analysis (A Case Study of Haigher RCC Dam)

Document Type : Research Article


1 Geotechnical MSc Student, Department of Civil Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Yasouj University, Yasouj, Iran

2 Assistant Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Yasouj University, Yasouj, Iran.

3 Associate Professor, Department of Soil Science, Faculty of Agriculture, Yasouj University, Yasouj, Iran

4 Geological Engineer, Ab Niroo Consulting Engineers, Haigher dam, Firoozabad, Fars, Iran


The issue of water seepage from foundations and abutments is one of the main challenges related to the design and construction of dams. One of the most important parameters in dam design in the study of seepage is to determine the permeability of the dam site, especially in rock formations. In this study, first, the permeability of Haigher roller compacted concrete dam site, located in Fars province, was determined through extensive Lugeon tests before and after the grout curtain. Then, using PLAXIS 3D FEM software, the site topography was modeled in three dimensions and three-dimensional dam seepage analysis was performed. The efficiency of the grout curtain was evaluated using numerical analysis. The results show that the total seepage discharge in the Haigher dam construction site without grout curtain is 1.075 * 10-2 m3/s and after the construction of the grout curtain is reduced to 2.305 × 10-3 m3/s, which indicates a reduction of about 80% seepage discharge. The results of the parametric study showed that with increasing the depth of the grout curtain, the seepage flow decreases and with increasing the reservoir water level, the seepage flow rate from the dam increases linearly.


Main Subjects

[1] R. Ajalloeian, E. Kasiri Dolatabadi, M. Pasandi and M. Rezaei, Evaluation of sedimentary formations of Tangab Semirom dam site with emphasis on leakage. Stratigraphy and Sedimentology Research, 27(43) (2011) 119-136. (In Persian)
[2] A. Fransson, C.F. Tsang, J. Rutqvist and G. Gustafson, A new parameter to assess hydromechanical effects in single–hole hydraulic testing and grouting, International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Science, 44 (2007) 1011-1021.
[3] H.R. Barani, G. Lashkaripour and M. Ghafoori, Predictive permeability model of faults in crystalline rocks: verification by joint hydraulic factor (JH) obtained from water pressure tests, Journal of Earth System Science, 123(6) (2014) 1325-1334. (In Persian)
[4] A. Uromeihy and R. Farrokhi, Evaluating groutability at the Kamal-Saleh dam based on Lugeon tests. Bulletin of Engineering Geology and the Environment, 71(2) (2012) 215-219.
[5] F.K. Ewert, Permeability and groutability and grouting of rocks related to dam sites, Dam Engineering, VIII (3) (1997) 215-248.
[6] M.E. Harr, Groundwater and Seepage. Mc Graw Hill, New York, (1962).
[7] B. Tokhmechi, H. Memarian, B. Moshiri, V. Rasouli and H. A. Noubari, Investigating the Validity of Conventional Joint set Clustering Methods, Engineering Geology, 118(3) (2011) 75-81. (In Persian)
[8] M. Abbasi, M. Ghafouri and A. Uromeihy, Comparison of Lugeon and Slurry Feed Number in Ardak Dam Injection Operation. Iran Engineering Geology and Environment Conference, (2007). (In Persian)
[9] H. Seyedi, M. Karami Moghaddam and M. Azari Dehkordi, Three-dimensional control of seepage in the Ala Dowlat Dam (Fars Province) using numerical finite element method, 4th National Congress of Civil Engineering, University of Tehran, (2008). (In Persian)
[10] M. Ghafouri, G. Lashkaripour, T. Moradi and F. Salehi Motahed, Assessment of seepage from the Inner dam based on water pressure test. The First National Conference on Infrastructure Engineering and Management, Tehran University of Technology (2009). (In Persian)
[11] S.R. Alavi and P. Maarefvand, Seepage analysis of Zhaveh dam site using Seep/w software, 4th International Conference on Geotechnical Engineering and Soil Mechanics of Iran, Tehran (2010). (In Persian)
[12]  M. Naeemi and H. Bayati, Study of the effect of sealing curtain on leakage reduction by increasing the penetration depth in the axis and the right support of Mirzai Shirazi reservoir dam numerically. Sixth National Congress of Civil Engineering (2011). (In Persian)
[13] P. Razi, M. Masoudi and S. Soltani Mohammadi, Selecting the optimal relationship between Lougan number and equivalent permeability in Seymareh dam injection operation (2013). (In Persian)
[14] N. Esmail Nia, A. Vaezi Hir, A. Asghari Moghadam and A. Hajipour, Investigation of leakage mechanism from the supports of Aghchai dam, Qara Zia-ud-Din, West Azerbaijan. 18th Conference of the Geological Society of Iran, Geological Society of Iran, (2014). (In Persian)
 [15] A. Parsa Sadr, M. Ajami and A. Akhtarpour, Evaluation of sealing efficiency using seepage analysis method in Stelj Qazvin reservoir dam, First National Conference on Soil Mechanics and Foundation Engineering, Faculty of Civil Engineering, Tarbiat Dabir Shahid Rajaei University, Tehran (2014). (In Persian)
[16] A. Emamalizadeh-Ghanati, E. Asghari Kaljahi and M. Bashirgonbadi, Determining the optimal depth of the sealing wall of Jolfa Gardian dam based on water leakage analysis with Seep/W software, Hydrogeology, 1(1) (2016) 93-106. (In Persian)
[17] M. Akbarzadeh, N. Hafezi Moqaddas and Gh. Lashkaripour, Effect of grout curtain on seepage rate from Damghan earthen dam using Seep / w software. First International Conference on Research and Development in Earth Sciences, Shiraz (2016). (In Persian)
[18] S. Ouhadi and G. Barani, Seepage modeling from the foundation and body of earth dams using finite element method, Iranian Journal of Irrigation and Drainage, 12(5) (2018) 1229-1239. (In Persian)
[19] B. Fotohi, M. Talkhabloo, S. M. Fatemi Aghda and J. Momeni, Three-dimensional modeling and analysis of Bakhtiari Dam permeability in order to design the grout curtain, Thesis for obtaining a master's degree in engineering geology, Kharazmi University (2018). (In Persian)
[20] H. Moghimi, F. Ravash and M. Keshavarz Bakhshaish, Study of water pressure test capability in calculating the seepage rate of Seymareh dam sealing curtain in Ilam province, Hydrogeology, 5(1) (2020) 1–15. (In Persian)
[21] S. Turkmen, Treatment of the seepage problems at the Kalecik dam (Turkey). Engineering Geology, 68 (3-4) (2003) 159-169.
[22] M.S. Pakbaz, A. Dardaei and J. Salahshoor, Evaluation of performance of plastic concert cut-off wall in Karkheh dam using 3-D seepage analysis and measurement, Journal of Applied Science, 9(4) (2009) 724-730.
[23] E. Wang, J. Zhong, Y. Zhao and W. Mao, Analysis of seepage and seepage control measures in the rock masses of the Huilong pumped-storage power station, Bulletin of Engineering Geology and the Environment, 74(4) (2015) 1453-1462.
[24] M. Yousefi, M. Sedghi-Asl and M. Parvizi, Seepage and boiling around a sheet pile under different experimental configuration, Journal of Hydrologic Engineering, 21(12) (2016) 06016015.
[25] M. Hosseini and S. Sazandeh, A numerical modeling study for determining the optimal depth of grout curtain in foundation and abutments of Karun IV dam. Journal of Analytical and Numerical Methods in Mining Engineering, 6 (Special Issue) (2017) 41-53.
[26] L.A. Saleh, Studying the seepage phenomena under a concrete dam using SEEP/W and Artificial Neural Network models. In IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, 433(1) (2018) 12-29. 
[27] M.N. Krikar, I. Hawkar Hashim and H. Ahmed Mohammed, Influence of upstream blanket on earth dam seepage. 4th International Engineering Conference on Developments in Civil & Computer Engineering Applications, (2018) 178-188.
 [28] J. Ashjari, F. Soltani and M. Rezai, Prediction of groundwater seepage caused by unclogging of fractures and grout curtain dimensions changes via numerical double-porosity model in the Karun IV river basin (Iran), Environmental earth sciences, 78(3) (2019) 78-85. (In Persian)
[29] K. Meshkabadi and Y. Zandi,­ The effects of grout curtain parameters on uplift and piping phenomenon; case study: Sattarkhan dam. Hydrology, 6(3) (2019) 71-85.
 [30] H. Li, F. Zhao and J. Li, Seepage analysis of clay core wall dam based on ABAQUS. In IOP Conference Series, Earth and Environmental Science, IOP Publishing, 384(1) (2019) 012015.
[31] K.R. Dhawan, S. Burele and K. Bagwan, Curtain Grouting, a tool used for stopping the seepage from an existing dam. Indian Geotechnical Journal, 49(5) (2019) 552-565.
[32] C. Bai, J. Chai, Z. Xu and Y. Qin, Numerical simulation of drainage holes and performance evaluation of the seepage control of gravity dam: a case study of Heihe reservoir in China. Arabian Journal for Science and Engineering, (2021) 1-19.
[33] M. Mozafari, P. Milanović and J. Jamei, Water leakage problems at the Tangab dam reservoir (SW Iran), case study of the complexities of dams on karst. Bulletin of Engineering Geology and the Environment, 80(10) (2021) 7989-8007.
[34] Ab-Niroo Consulting Engineers Co., Geoglogy report of Haigher Dam project (2006).
[35] C. Rozo, Lugeon test interpretation, revisited. In Collaborative management of integrated watersheds, US Society of Dams, 30th annual conference, (2010) 405-414.
[36] Ab-Niroo Consulting Engineers Co., Technical specifications of Haigher Dam project (2007).
[37] Ab-Niroo Consulting Engineers Company, Report of Grout curtain studies and geotechnical investigations of Haigher Dam (2011-2021).
[38] B.M. Das and K. Sobhan, Principles of geotechnical engineering. SI Edition, 9th Edition (2018).