A bibliometric analysis on incineration ash during 2000 to 2020

Document Type : Research Article


1 Department of Civil Engineering, K.N. Toosi University of Technology

2 Postdoctoral researcher at Technical University of Berlin


Even though incineration has been extensively studied by many researchers, a few bibliometric analyzes have been presented in this area. This bibliometric paper aims to value the research trend and identify the most used topics in the field of "incinerator ash" during the years 2000 to 2020 by social network analysis comprehensively. This research includes examining document type, distribution of journals, the activity of institutes and countries, language, and keywords. The results show that among the 6,179 publications surveyed related to incinerators, more than 57% of them belong to the field of environment and the number of publications in 2020 was almost four times larger than the ones in 2000. “China” has played a key role in publishing among the countries, followed by Japan and the United States. “Waste Management” was the leading scientific journal in the field with a total of 579 articles related to incinerators, and the “Journal of Cleaner Production” had the most growth. The keywords “fly ash”, “heavy metals” and “bottom ash” have been the most frequently used keywords in 21 years. In recent years, words related to stabilization and solidification have been among the most widely used words, which shows the growth of this category of research. The significant growth of the words in the newfound fields of “life cycle assessment” and “sustainable development” as well as laboratory incineration-related research containing “XRD” and “SEM” can also be seen. The paper results provide a better comprehension of recent research and can also affect forthcoming research in this field.


Main Subjects

[1] T. Thriveni, C. Ramakrishna, A.J. Whan, Simultaneous CO2 Sequestration of Korean Municipal Solid Waste Incineration Bottom Ash and Encapsulation of Heavy Metals by Accelerated Carbonation, in:  Energy Technology 2019, (2019) 81-89.
[2] T. Nakakubo, N. Yoshida, Y. Hattori, Analysis of greenhouse gas emission reductions by collaboratively updating equipment in sewage treatment and municipal solid waste incineration plants, Journal of Cleaner Production, 168 (2017) 803-813.
[3] B. Liu, Q.-W. Yang, S.-G. Zhang, Integrated utilization of municipal solid waste incineration fly ash and bottom ash for preparation of foam glass–ceramics, Rare Metals, 38(10) (2019) 914-921.
[4] M. Bruno, M. Abis, K. Kuchta, F.-G. Simon, R. Grönholm, M. Hoppe, S. Fiore, Material flow, econ omic and environmental assessment of municipal solid waste incineration bottom ash recycling potential in Europe, Journal of Cleaner Production, 317 (2021).
[5] P. Wang, Y. Hu, H. Cheng, Municipal solid waste (MSW) incineration fly ash as an important source of heavy metal pollution in China, Environ Pollut 252 (2019) 461–475.
[6] Y. Liu, K.A. Clavier, C. Spreadbury, T.G. Townsend, Limitations of the TCLP fluid determination step for hazardous waste characterization of US municipal waste incineration ash, Waste Manag, 87(2019) 590-596.
[7] A. Assi, F. Bilo, A. Zanoletti, J. Ponti, A. Valsesia, R. La Spina, A. Zacco, E. Bontempi, Zero-waste approach in municipal solid waste incineration: Reuse of bottom ash to stabilize fly ash, Journal of Cleaner Production, 245 (2020).
[8] M.J. Quina, E. Bontempi, A. Bogush, S. Schlumberger, G. Weibel, R. Braga, V. Funari, J. Hyks , E.Rasmussen, J. Lederer, Technologies for the management of MSW incineration ashes from gas cleaning: New perspectives on recovery of secondary raw materials and circular economy, Sci Total Environ 635 (2018) 526–542.
[9] D. Xuan, P. Tang, C.S. Poon, Limitations and quality upgrading techniques for utilization of MSW incineration bottom ash in engineering applications – A review, Construction and Building Materials, 190 (2018) 1091-1102.
[10] W.-D. Fan, B. Liu, X. Luo, J. Yang, B. Guo, S.-G. Zhang, Production of glass–ceramics using Municipal solid waste incineration fly ash, Rare Metals, 38(3) (2017) 245-251.
[11] M. Nikravan, A.A. Ramezanianpour, R. Maknoon, Study on physiochemical properties and leaching behavior of residual ash fractions from a municipal solid waste incinerator (MSWI) plant, J Environ Manage 260 (2020).
[12] A.A. Ramezanianpour, M. Nikravan, R. Maknoon, Characterization of bottom ash from petrochemical waste incinerator, J Residuals Sci Technol 8 (2011) 189–196.
[13] R. Cossu, T. Lai, K. Pivnenko, Waste washing pre-treatment of municipal and special waste, J Hazard Mater, 207-208 (2012) 65-72.
[14] G. Gupta, M. Datta, G.V. Ramana, B.J. Alappat, MSW incineration bottom ash (MIBA) as a substitute to conventional materials in geotechnical applications: A characterization study from India and comparison with literature, Constr Build Mater 308, 124925 (2021).
[15] S. Seraj, M. Nikravan, A.A. Ramezanianpour, P. Zendehdel, Evaluation of the application of municipal solid waste incinerator (MSWI) ash in civil engineering using a sustainability approach, Detritus 9 (2020) 113–124.
[16] L. Diaz Caselles, C. Roosz, J. Hot, S. Blotevogel, M. Cyr, Immobilization of molybdenum by alternative cementitious binders and synthetic C-S-H: An experimental and numerical study, Sci Total Environ, 789 (2021) 148069.
[17] Y. Wang, H. Xu, C. Chen, X. Wang, H. Zhang, X. Wu, L. Cai, Enhanced solidification/stabilization of lead in MSWI fly ash treatment and disposal by gelatinized sticky rice, Environ Technol (United Kingdom) 42(10) (2021) 1531–1541.
[18] B.H. Cho, B.H. Nam, J. An, H. Youn, Municipal Solid Waste Incineration (MSWI) Ashes as Construction Materials-A Review, Materials (Basel), 13(14) (2020).
[19] J. Bawab, J. Khatib, S. Kenai, M. Sonebi, A Review on Cementitious Materials Including Municipal Solid Waste Incineration Bottom Ash (MSWI-BA) as Aggregates, Buildings, 11(5) (2021).
[20] J. Tang, B.M. Steenari, Leaching optimization of municipal solid waste incineration ash for resource recovery: A case study of Cu, Zn, Pb and Cd, Waste Manag, 48 (2016) 315–322.
[21]J. Haberl, M. Schuster, Solubility of elements in waste incineration fly ash and bottom ash under various leaching conditions studied by a sequential extraction procedure, Waste Manag, 87 (2019)268-278.
[22] A. Zacco, L. Borgese, A. Gianoncelli, R.P.W.J. Struis, L.E. Depero, E. Bontempi, Review of fly ash inertisation treatments and recycling, Environmental Chemistry Letters, 12(1) (2014) 153-175.
[23] M. Margallo, M.B.M. Taddei, A. Hernández-Pellón, R. Aldaco, Á. Irabien, Environmental sustainability assessment of the management of municipal solid waste incineration residues: a review of the current situation, Clean Technologies and Environmental Policy, 17(5) (2015) 1333-1353.
[24] C. Fan, B. Wang, Y. Qi, Z. Liu, Characteristics and leaching behavior of MSWI fly ash in novel solidification/stabilization binders, Waste Manag 131 (2021) 277–285.
[25] V.D. Martinho, P.R. Mourão, Circular Economy and Economic Development in the European Union: A Review and Bibliometric Analysis, Sustainability, 12(18) (2020).
[26] F. Savini, The circular economy of waste: recovery, incineration and urban reuse, Journal of Environmental Planning and Management, 64(12) (2021) 2114-2132.
[27] A. Mary Joseph, R. Snellings, P. Nielsen, S. Matthys, N. De Belie, Pre-treatment and utilisation of municipal solid waste incineration bottom ashes towards a circular economy, Construction and Building Materials, 260 (2020).
[28] T. Bakalár, H. Pavolová, Z. Hajduová, R. Lacko, K. Kyšeľa, Metal recovery from municipal solid waste incineration fly ash as a tool of circular economy, Journal of Cleaner Production, 302 (2021).
[29] L. Reijnders, Disposal, uses and treatments of combustion ashes: a review, Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 43(3) (2005) 313-336.
[30] Y. Wang, N. Lai, J. Zuo, G. Chen, H. Du, Characteristics and trends of research on waste-to-energy incineration: A bibliometric analysis, 1999–2015, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 66 (2016) 95-104.
[31] Scopus, https://www.scopus.com/search/form.uri?display=basic (2021) Data extracted on March 2020
[32] N.J. Van Eck, L. Waltman, Manual for VOSviwer version 1.6.10. CWTS Meaningful metrics (2019)1–53.
[33] G. Mao, X. Liu, H. Du, J. Zuo, L. Wang, Way forward for alternative energy research: A bibliometric analysis during 1994–2013, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 48 (2015) 276-286.
[34] A.F.J. Raan, Measurement : Interdisciplinary Research and Perspectives For Your Citations Only? Hot Topics in Bibliometric Analysis. Interdiscip Res Perspect 31, 50-62 (2009) 37–41.
[35] G. Mao, H. Zou, G. Chen, H. Du, J. Zuo, Past, current and future of biomass energy research: A bibliometric analysis, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 52 (2015) 1823-1833.
[36] J. Dong, Y. Chi, D. Zou, C. Fu, Q. Huang, M. Ni, Energy–environment–economy assessment of waste management systems from a life cycle perspective: Model development and case study, Applied Energy, 114 (2014) 400-408.
[37] J.L. Aleixandre-Tudo, L. Castelló-Cogollos, J.L. Aleixandre, R. Aleixandre-Benavent, Unravelling the scientific research on grape and wine phenolic compounds: a bibliometric study, Scientometrics, 119(1) (2019) 119-147.
[38] C. Michael Hall, Publish and perish? Bibliometric analysis, journal ranking and the assessment of research quality in tourism, Tourism Management, 32(1) (2011) 16-27.
[39] A. Mostafa Hatami, M.R. Sabour, M. Nikravan, A systematic analysis of research trends on incineration during 2000–2019, International Journal of Environmental Science and Technology, 18(2) (2020) 353-364.
[40] Y. Xing, H. Zhang, W. Su, Q. Wang, H. Yu, J. Wang, R. Li, C. Cai, Z. Ma, The bibliometric analysis and review of dioxin in waste incineration and steel sintering, Environ Sci Pollut Res, 26 (2019) 35687–35703.
[41] S. Wong, A.X.Y. Mah, A.H. Nordin, B.B. Nyakuma, N. Ngadi, R. Mat, N.A.S. Amin, W.S. Ho, T.H. Lee, Emerging trends in municipal solid waste incineration ashes research: a bibliometric analysis from 1994 to 2018, Environ Sci Pollut Res, 27 (2020) 7757–7784.
[42] M.R. Sabour, E. Alam, A.M. Hatami, Global trends and status in landfilling research: a systematic analysis, Journal of Material Cycles and Waste Management, 22(3) (2020) 711-723. 
[43] Z. Ye, B. Zhang, Y. Liu, J. Zhang, Z. Wang, H. Bi, A bibliometric investigation of research trends on sulfate removal,  Desalination and Water Treatment, 52(31-33) (2013) 6040-6049.
[44] E. Otte, R. Rousseau, Social network analysis: a powerful strategy, also for the information sciences, Journal of Information Science, 28(6) (2016) 441-453.
[45]    X. Zhao, J. Zuo, G. Wu, C. Huang, A bibliometric review of green building research 2000–2016, Architectural Science Review, 62(1) (2018) 74-88.
[46] C. Gao, M. Sun, Y. Geng, R. Wu, W. Chen, A bibliometric analysis based review on wind power price, Applied Energy, 182 (2016) 602-612.
[47] D.N. Effendi, Irwandani, W. Anggraini, A. Jatmiko, H. Rahmayanti, I.Z. Ichsan, M. Mehadi Rahman, Bibliometric analysis of scientific literacy using VOS viewer: Analysis of science education, Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 1796(1) (2021).
[48] L. Meng, K.-H. Wen, R. Brewin, Q. Wu, Knowledge Atlas on the Relationship between Urban Street Space and Residents’ Health—A Bibliometric Analysis Based on VOSviewer and CiteSpace, Sustainability, 12(6) (2020).
[49]C. Velmurugan, G. Ramasamy, Nephrology Publications of Bibliographic Coupling and Co-authorship Network using VOS viewer: A Scientometric Profile, Libr Philos Pract 2021 (2021).
[50] N.J. van Eck, L. Waltman, Software survey: VOSviewer, a computer program for bibliometric mapping, Scientometrics, 84(2) (2010) 523-538.
[51] K. Obileke, H. Onyeaka, O. Omoregbe, G. Makaka, N. Nwokolo, P. Mukumba, Bioenergy from bio-waste: a bibliometric analysis of the trend in scientific research from 1998–2018, Biomass Conversion and Biorefinery, (2020).
[52] W. Ahmad, A. Ahmad, K.A. Ostrowski, F. Aslam, P. Joyklad, A scientometric review of waste material utilization in concrete for sustainable construction, Case Studies in Construction Materials, 15 (2021).
[53] F.D.B. de Sousa, Management of plastic waste: A bibliometric mapping and analysis, Waste Manag Res, 39(5) (2021) 664-678.
[54] SCImago Journal Rank, https://www.scimagojr.com (2021) Data extracted on March 2021 
[55] J.E. Hirsch, An index to quantify an individual’s scientific research output, Proc Natl Acad Sci, 102 (2005) 16569–16572.
[56] G. Rosenthal, Economic and Social Council. Oxford Handb United Nations 14898  (2009).
[57] J.W. Lu, S. Zhang, J. Hai, M. Lei, Status and perspectives of municipal solid waste incineration in China: A comparison with developed regions, Waste Manag, 69 (2017) 170-186.
[58] M.S. Rahaman, K.M.N. Ansari, H. Kumar, K. Shah, Mapping and Visualizing Research Output on Global Solid Waste Management: A Bibliometric Review of Literature, Science & Technology Libraries, (2021) 1-29.